Thursday, April 5, 2018

LEX ORANDI, LEX CREDENDI - THE INQUIRING AND DISCERNING HEART


This homily was delivered at Christ Episcopal Church in Yankton, South Dakota on February 18, 2018 on the First Sunday in Lent.

Not being raised an Episcopalian, one of the prayers that caught my attention when Kathy and I joined this church occurred when we witnessed our first baptism here. 

The prayer goes like this:

Heavenly Father, we thank you that by water and the Holy Spirit you have bestowed upon these your servants the forgiveness of sin, and have raised them to new life of grace.  Sustain them, O Lord, in your Holy Spirit.  Give them an inquiring and discerning heart, the courage to will and to persevere, a spirit to know and to love you, and the gift of joy and wonder in all your works.[1]

This quickly became one of my favorite prayers in The Book of Common Prayer.  Lex orandi, lex credendi (what we pray reflects our deepest beliefs), as intimated in this prayer, acknowledges that the heart is shaped by what it seeks and especially by what it finds to be true.

Questioning has not been held in high regard throughout much of the church’s history and remains so in some Christian churches.  Yet in the Anglican tradition, our tradition, we have a unique theological perspective that shapes our identity as Episcopalians.  The 16th century English Theologian, Richard Hooker, wrote:

“What scripture doth plainly deliver, to that the first place both of credit and obedience are due; the next whereunto, is what a man can necessarily conclude by force of Reason; after this, the voice of the church succeedeth”.[2]   

This has become known as the three-legged stool upon which Anglican theological perspective is derived: Scripture, Reason, and Tradition.  There were few Christian denominations at that time and since that time that have given human reason, by itself, a place of prominence in theological discernment and discourse. What makes us unique among the Christian family of denominations is that we honor the human faculty of reason as essential in discerning the will of God in the light of Scripture and by its reflective wisdom embedded in our traditions.

Two individuals baptized as Anglicans came to mind as I thought about this prayer:  Charles Darwin and Thomas Merton; both examples of individuals with an inquiring and discerning heart.

CHARLES DARWIN

Born to a free thinking father and a Unitarian mother, Charles was baptized in the Church of England, the Anglican Communion.  Before taking his fateful journey aboard the Beagle in which he weighed the plethora of possibilities why so many diverse life forms in the world exist, Darwin had seriously considered taking Holy Orders and becoming a curate in the Church of England.  In reading his life story, I came to appreciate the struggle he had with the knowledge he acquired; whether to publish his findings that he knew would cause controversy and put him in a spotlight he did not seek.   He sat on the knowledge his experiences gave him for decades and only published his famous “Origen of the Species” when friends pleaded with him to do so.  The weight of his reasoned discoveries and the inner conflict it caused him took a toll on his health.

Our understanding of the world was forever changed by his reasoning mind; his inquiring and discerning heart.  Advances in the field of medical science are largely traced to what he revealed.  Charles Darwin not only broadened our understanding of who we are and how we came to be and the world we live in, he also broadened our understanding of God.  While that may not have been his intent nor would he have thought it a result of his work, it certainly was an outcome of it; traceable to God’s intent working through him. His findings brought many religious communities, including our own, to rediscover the deeper meaning of their scriptures and their traditions in a new and brighter light.

In 2011, when Kathy and I took our daughters on a post-graduation tour of Ireland and Great Britain, we visited West Minister Abbey in London.  Appropriately, Charles Darwin, an admitted agnostic in later life, was laid to rest in its hallowed nave by a supporting church faithful in its vow to support him at his baptism. As I stood looking down on his tomb, a few steps from the elaborate tomb of Sir Isaac Newton in the north aisle, marked by a single marble slab bearing his name, I could not help but think of him as a saint; a person who gifted us with a deeper appreciation of the joy and wonder of God’s work in all creation.  Fortunately for us, Charles Darwin found the courage to will and persevere, whose integrity in speaking the truth of his experience reflected the integrity of God’s truth expressed in all creation.

THOMAS MERTON

Thomas Merton was the 20th Century Trappist Monk who reintroduced Western Christianity to contemplative practices. Merton was baptized an Anglican in the Pyrenees of South France.  Educated in France and in Cambridge England, he didn’t seem drawn to religion in his early life.  At one point in his life, he claimed to be an agnostic and fathered a child out of wedlock. 

It wasn’t until some years later that he met a Hindu monk, Brahmachari, who sparked his interest in religious life, but instead of pointing Thomas to Hinduism, he pointed him back to his own religious roots, Christianity, and told him to start there.  Merton eventually became a Trappist monk at the Abbey of Gethsemane in Indiana. His books on contemplative prayer and his life journey are considered Christian classics.  His groundbreaking work in interfaith dialogue with Buddhists, like Thich Nhat Hanh, helped Christians everywhere better understand our scriptures and traditions through the lens of what others have to offer. 

My reason for briefly sharing their stories is that we don’t know what wonders God will perform through those baptized into Christ or where their journey will lead them and us.  Both Darwin and Merton encountered experiences that drew out a faith that shattered previous held beliefs for them and for us.  Both demonstrated what I would call the integrity of faith by embracing their experiences, learning from them, and sharing the knowledge garnered from them with the world.

BAPTISM

In the ritual of baptism we witness a symbolic reorientation to one’s original state of grace – the death of a prejudicial worldview that only sees sin and a sinner; a presentation of the clean slate that every newborn and every reborn represents.  Baptism is a symbolic reset of creation to the goodness that it is.  This is Christ’s mission in the world; a mission we share.  In that reset, we honor the creative Spirit of God that each of us has been proportioned; the inquiring and discerning heart that in its individuality is uniquely in sync with the mind of Christ and the will of God in ways that stretch the imagination.  

I have come to see baptism as something that should change how we see the person being baptized; a wiping away of our prejudicial biases; to look at the recipient of this ritual sacrament as a grace filled child of God who is set on a journey of inquiry and discernment, no matter what their age or the circumstances they come from.  We need to remember that regardless of where that journey leads them, we have pledged them our support.   In this baptismal prayer, the path to knowing and loving God in the joy and wonder of creation is opened in ways for the baptized that we cannot see or understand at the time.

DISCERNING THE WAY FORWARD

This prayer also reminds me of the journey this congregation is currently on. We are all headed towards something; an ending that is likely a beginning whether we like it or know what that means and nothing brings this to the forefront of a congregation’s awareness than when it loses a pastor and is faced with searching for someone to shepherd its flock.

Now is the time for using our inquiring and discerning hearts. 

Now is the time to find the courage to will and persevere.

Discernment is a unique process that asks us to listen deeply to the heart of this congregation in order to find the mind of Christ in our journey forward.   Anyone who has experienced a discernment process for ministry knows that it is not so much about exercising one’s will as it is about letting go of it and letting God lead the way forward.

Thomas Merton wrote what is probably one of the best personal prayers regarding discerning the way forward which I am paraphrasing for our collective use:

OUR LORD GOD, We have no idea where we are going. We do not see the road ahead of us. We cannot know for certain where it will end. Nor do we really know ourselves, and the fact that we think that we are following your will does not mean that we are actually doing so. But we believe that the desire to please you does in fact please you. And we hope we have that desire in all that we are doing. We hope that we will never do anything apart from that desire. And we know that if we do this you will lead us by the right road though we may know nothing about it. Therefore, will we trust you always though we may seem to be lost and in the shadow of death. We will not fear, for you are ever with us, and you will never leave us to face our perils alone.[3]

Amen.




[1] “The Book of Common Prayer,”  The Church Hymnal Corporation, New York, 1979, pg. 308
[2] Richard Hooker in “Laws of Ecclesial Polity.”
[3] Thomas Merton, (paraphrased) see original version From “Through the Year with Thomas Merton”  

No comments:

Post a Comment